There are some wars I'm just not willing to wage with my children. If Charlotte wants to wear mismatched socks pulled up to her knees with Dora slippers on to the store, whatever. She's expressing herself and as long as she's safe, who am I to quell her independence?
She has a very distinct bedtime routine. I mean, if you forget something or put something out of place, she flips her shit. Thankfully, it's the only time she's so anal and I think it has to do with her needing to control to feel safe, especially once she gave up her pacifier. So, I give her that.
She took her "bippy" till she was almost three. Though I didn't want it to affect her teeth, part of me didn't care. It made her feel safe. It was her comfort. After she turned 20 months or so, I made her keep it in her bed and she could only use it for naptime and bedtime. And occasionally in the car, mostly because I wanted to plug her whine-hole while trapped in a moving vehicle.
Sawyer never took a pacifier. Ok, I lie. He took it for like the first four months or so, until he got his first cold. He was too stuffy to suck on it for a couple of nights, and after that he would spit it out or chomp on it but never suck it. Mike and I took it as a sign to throw away all remaining bippies and save ourselves the agony of going through what we went through with Charlotte (who willingly gave them up, never asking for them, but created a months-long battle of getting out of her bed repeatedly that damn near drove me over the edge of the precipice I call my sanity).
He has a bunch of silky blankets and stuffed animals he likes to sleep with, but has no real preference. Any one will do, which is great. His vice? His bottle.
I'm sure you've seen me on Twitter lamenting about how I'm sure he'll be 35 and still carry a BPA-free "bot" in his briefcase. He still takes THREE-FOUR bottles a day. I've been able to eliminate the morning one since he finally sleeps till 7 and then we just get up and have breakfast. He still takes two naps, and before each one he takes a bottle. And then the obligatory one before bedtime.
As soon as he gets tired or when he's scared or upset, he cries, "Bot! Bot! Bot!" For instance, when I bring him to the gym daycare, he immediately starts crying because he's a momma's boy and doesn't like when I leave a room. I hand him a bottle and he plugs up and walks over and starts playing. If I'm at the supermarket and he starts acting up or whining because I won't let him squish my bread or pull things off the shelves, I give him his bottle and he calms down. It's his soother. It calms him.
I just can't bring myself to take it away.
I remember when Charlotte was his age, she was already off the bottle, drinking her milk in a cup. I'd see older babies with bottles and smugly be proud of my awesome parenting skills. Oh, how I'd love to punch my past self squarely in the throat.
We've tried to put milk in his sippy cup, but he won't drink it. He'll literally throw it on the ground. He loves his sippies and has been taking them since he was 7 months old. But he wants his water/juice (due to constipation issues - most likely due to the crazy amount of dairy he intakes - he also drinks like 2-3 full sippies a day of watered-down apple juice) in his sippy cup and his milk in his "bot." Nothing else will do. Juice in a bottle? Milk in a cup? BLASPHEMER. He won't do it.
So for now, it's a battle I'm not willing to fight. We're going to Disney in a couple of weeks. He'll be on a plane for the first time, staying in a strange hotel, skipping naps, etc. He needs his bottle to get through that. Hell, WE need his bottle to get through that.
Then when we get back we'll try to get him down to only his nighttime bottle. Baby steps, right? Sometimes I get comments. Some are good - like the daycare lady at the gym. She says "Oh heck, my last daughter took a bottle till she was three!!" or his dayhome provider, "he's still a baby." Some are not good, like the old lady in the supermarket, "My, isn't he a big boy to have a bottle?" SUCK IT, GRANNY.
He IS still a baby. And for now, I can't bring myself to take away something that soothes him, calms him down, and quite frankly, shut his hole.
(This is where you comment and tell me YOUR kid took a bottle to college. Or give me some magic trick to get him to drink milk from a cup after vacation.)
Thursday, October 1, 2009
Choosing battles
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



17 comments:
It's all just so funny to me. When my boys, now 21 and 19, were babies the rules were different. You potty trained by 2 and let them have the bottle until they were ready, just no sleeping with them. Then I had the girls, new rules. Get rid of that bottle by 1, and hell, let them go to college in a diaper if that's what makes them comfy.
IMO, it's all just to sell new parenting books. If the advice always stayed the same, no need for new books, mags and the like.
What I've learned, we did what worked for us and listened to none of the advice. We went by our childrens' cues and it all worked out well. No 21, 19, 11 & 9, all off the bottle, no pacifiers, and none feel the need to regress back into their Pampers.
You are doing the right thing for your family. Screw what anyone else's opinion is.
He's still a baby! Babies need comfort. You do what you have to do to get through the day and if his college professors have a problem with that, well, THEY can take it up with him.
Our situation is different in that both kids were breastfed to past a year. My daughter was a challenge to get on the bottle, and my son is shaping up to be the same. Bottom line, they never LOVED bottles, so taking them away was/shouldn't be difficult (he says knowing that fate will now smite him).
You do what's best for your children. You should of heard all the comments people said about me rocking my little girl to sleep every night till she was over a year. Then I had my son and he wanted nothing to do with me when he wanted to sleep and I missed that so much.
I agree that you do what is best for your child. Follow their cues, not what Granny or the baby books say. That's my moto anyhow!
Oh, the massive amounts of throat-punching I want to do to pre-baby me, with my smug know-it-all parenting skills gained solely from watching hours of SuperNanny.
Each kid is different. They give up baby things when they're ready to stop being a baby. Is it worth fighting? Probably not.
Bryan's oldest is now nine and still sucks his thumb. This grates me nerves TO NO END and yet? HOW DO YOU FORCE HIM TO QUIT?
I am horrible at picking battles (see that gray hair? bad battle picker!)
Anyway, I was fortunate that my kids transitioned well from bottle to sippy, all around a year. That was about the easiest thing that my kids have done so far in their lives. So, I'm no help. :)
But, you have to do what is best for you. It's the only thing you can do, even if others don't approve.
Chloe still has bottles - she has about 2 per day. I don't see what the big issue is. She's still a baby (toddler, I guess) and she's not 2.
Maybe I'll fight the battle one day. I'm not ready.
For us, the bottle and potty training went hand in hand, simply because they get so much fluid from bottles. And I felt like it was a losing battle to give Matt a bottle and then expect him to regulate his pee.
Having said that. He was 3 when he gave up the bottle and then just over 3 when he toilet trained.
It was when he was ready.
But, then it was easy.
As for quitting bottles. My parenting rocks.
To introduce a bottle (since he was breastfed) I gave him chocolate milk and weaned him down to regular milk.
When I wanted to quit the bottle I started giving him chocolate milk again.
One night we ran out of chocolate milk and he refused to drink regular milk from a bottle.
Genius.
Out went the bottles.
I should write a parenting book! Other highlights would be bribery, freaking kids out about sugar bugs so they brush their teeth ...
I could go on and on.
You know you're an awesome mom :)
Charlotte was a milk/crack addict, so I just took the milk away for like 2.5 weeks- I would let her have the bottle but it would have water in it. After letting her dig through the refrigerator to prove there was no milk she finally just didn't care. After a few weeks without milk, she was so thankful to get it back she wouldn't have cared if I had made her lick it off the floor, much less drink from a sippie cup.
Take my advice with a grain of salt because I am kinda a cup nazi. I made her start drinking from a cup with no lid at 10 months and she only used sippie cups in the car or at other people's houses. I will now let her use cups with lids, but none of the no-spill stuff. I'm old school. I think kids will adapt to whatever we expect of them.
(I do fully expect my future self to punch me any moment for saying it that way- I am not trying to say it will be pretty just that it will happen. Please don't punch me)
Max is the same.Seriously, every part of this post I was nodding and saying "THAT'S MAX!" I'm not really worried about it though. He's 15 months old, and yea, I get the disapproving looks when we're out and he's got a bottle, but I just don't care at this point. I know he's not ready to give it up and I'm certainly not ready to deal with him giving it up right now.
Morgan was slow to change as well. I slowly started adding in milk with the formula and eventually got to the point where it was all milk. I also slip in yogurt drinks or pediasure to make it taste more appealing. As for the bottle that too took a while. I started attempting to give him the "Nuby" bottles because they were most like the "bot" and eventually he only wanted them — and that is when I put those suckers into storage (or in your case charity or recycle) faster than you can say "chihuahua cheese and crackers."
But those things (Nuby) leak and I don't know about your son, but mine loves to chuck that thing like he just scored a touchdown in the inzone. That often makes it leak faster. So as soon as he was willing I got him interested in the playtex twist and lock sippy and straw cups.
And that is my story. Now if only I could get him over his food eating issues. :/
i didnt have time to read other comments, but the trick that worked for me with both my kids was to make the milk CHOCOLATE. and once they got use to drinking it from the cup i wanted them to-then i would slowly reduce the amount of chocolate each time till it was all whole milk again. i hope when you get home from vaca-that you are victorious in your efforts!! good luck :)
My kid was never attached to anything really. She never took the pacifier and barely flinched when we stopped using a bottle. But she sucks her middle and ring fingers on her left hand and she will not stop. I wish her comfort came in the form of an object that could be taken away, but alas, it's not to be.
He'll give up the bottle. At least he's not refusing to drink anything out of a cup. Then you'd have trouble. But honestly, if you wanted to be harsh you could just take the bottles away and he'd eventually get thirsty and drink his milk from a cup. So no worries.
With my oldest son (now nearly 25) I went by what "they" recommended - at 15 months the bottle was GONE, and at 2 he was out of diapers and in underwear. Of course, for 8 months I changed and washed 8 sets of clothes A DAY, by by dog I was not letting him back in diapers since he was TWO. Fortunately, he didn't have an issue with letting go of his bottle.
Second son, 7 years later. At 19 months, his little sister was born, so I did not push giving up his bottle, knowing she was coming. I had him nearly weaned from it when he was 22 months, and then his sister died of SIDS. I was a wreck, daddy was a wreck, and there was NO WAY I could pull the little guy's last form of comfort at that time - he was highly attached to the bottle. I let him ease himself off, and by 28 months he was done with the bottle. Directly after that, he showed interest in potty training, so taking the cue from him we went for it. He was potty trained in THREE days, and not a single accident, including night, EVER!
This new set of babies I'm following my own instincts, just like I did with Kevin. Mila is 26 months old and hasd no interest in potty training. (Oh, please, pottys gods, show her the light! LOL) I also did not take her bottle from her like my pediatrician tried to insist when she was a year - I knew her baby brother was on the way and figured she needed some stability of comfort in her life - Did I mention I had placenta previa and was in and out of the hospital until Malachi was out of the danger zone so they could take him early? Malachi is 10 months old, and has no real attachment to the bottle. He does like one at bedtime, and one sometimes at naptime - but just as often he wants his binky and a little rocking instead. He's the only one of my five that ever showed any interest in a binky, so it will be interesting to see how it goes when it's time for him to give it up.
Sorry for the ramble...I just wanted to reinforce your own knowledge that you're not doing any harm in letting Sawyer keep his bot. I can virtually guarantee he won't start kindergarten with it.
Dh and I have always had a pretty strict policy about picking what we want to make a fuss about. Pretty much, my only requirements are that no clothes are revealing, and nothing aside from ears, noses or eyebrows are pierced. I generally don't care about clothes matching, or rooms being spotless, or even what color their hair will be when they're older. As long as there aren't any pierced lips or tongues, I'm good. 'Cause, gross.
What can I say that will be different from all the other, far more wiser commenters?
Nothing.
My kid had A bottle a day until she was 15 months old. My kid had her pacifier anytime she wanted until she was 2. Then, it was naps and bed or traveling only.
My shameful secret? She STILL has that damn thing! Only at nap and bed, but she STILL has that damn thing. She's THREE AND A HALF AND STILL HAS THE DAMN THING.
I'm convinced I have no idea what I'm doing as SHE STILL HAS THE DAMN THING and...AND still will NOT go on the $#@!*&# toilet. Seriously. Pull-Ups only, but WTF?!
This is now where I hang my head in Mommy Shame and slink away.
Let the boy have his bottle. Who the hell cares what anyone else says or thinks in a negative way. He's a baby. It's what soothes him. When you get back from Disney, then work on it.
I am a sucker when it comes to my kids. Neither were potty trained until almost 4; my oldest had his paci until he was ready to give it up on his own...about 3.5...my younger still HAS to have a sippy in bed (and seriously, it's JUST recently changed from diluted juice to water). My oldest, in order to give up his bottle? We went with a straw cup because he didn't want a sippy. He eventually took to the sippy and moved on.
All that to say, do what is right for your kids. They won't go to college with bottles or in diapers...and hell, if they do? Just pick up the therapy tab. :)
Post a Comment